Latest stories

The Cloth Carbon-Dated to the Middle Ages

The Shroud of Turin shows a scourged and crucified man. A bishop called it a forgery in the 1380s, three laboratories dated it to 1260-1390 in 1988, and how the image was made is still unexplained.

Evidence: moderate · Sourced: two or more sources, at least one beyond Wikipedia.

The Shroud of Turin is a linen cloth about 4.4 metres long and 1.1 metres wide, bearing the faint front-and-back image of a naked man. Millions believe it shows the body of Christ. The documented evidence is less simple.

The Horror

The cloth first appears in the 1350s at the church at Lirey in France, founded by the knight Geoffroi de Charny, where it was exhibited. A pilgrim badge from Lirey depicting it is dated to between 1355 and 1410. The sources vary on exact dates. Around 1389 or 1390 Bishop Pierre d’Arcis of Troyes wrote to the antipope Clement VII calling it a forgery, saying a previous bishop had identified the painter. Clement allowed it to be shown only as a representation and not as the true shroud of Christ.

In 1898 Secondo Pia photographed it, on 28 May, and the negative showed the image more clearly than the cloth itself. That discovery made the Shroud a modern puzzle.

In 1988 laboratories at Oxford, Arizona and ETH Zurich radiocarbon-dated a sample to AD 1260-1390 at 95% confidence. Most experts accept the result. Some defenders have argued the sample was a medieval repair or contaminated, and later statistical reanalyses have questioned the consistency of the lab data. How the image was made remains unexplained.

What is claimed

Pollen, dust and anatomical arguments are cited on both sides. Claims in popular retellings that investigators found pollen from the Jerusalem region, or that the wounds are anatomically exact and show nailing through the wrists, are unconfirmed here.

The Modern Relic

The Shroud was damaged by a fire on 4 December 1532, when molten silver from the reliquary burned holes through the folded cloth. Poor Clare nuns patched it in 1534. In 1578 it was moved to Turin, where it has remained.

On 11 April 1997 a fire struck Turin Cathedral. The Shroud was in a glass case, described as bulletproof and 39 mm thick. The firefighter Mario Trematore broke it with a sledgehammer, with another fireman helping, and the cloth was carried out unscathed. The cause of the fire is possibly arson.

The Church neither endorses nor rejects the Shroud’s authenticity, and John Paul II said it has no specific competence on the question. It is shown on rare exhibitions, including 2010, 2013 and 2015.

Still there todayThe Shroud is kept in Turin Cathedral and shown only on rare public exhibitions, the most recent listed in the source being in 2015. See it on the Dark Atlas →
Sources
  • Wikipedia, 'Shroud of Turin' — the cloth about 4.4 m by 1.1 m with a faint front-and-back image of a naked man, Secondo Pia photographing it on 28 May 1898 with the negative showing the image more clearly, Geoffroi de Charny's church at Lirey and the cloth being exhibited around 1355, a Lirey pilgrim badge dated 1355-1410, Bishop Pierre d'Arcis's 1389/1390 memorandum calling it a forgery and the antipope Clement VII allowing display only as a representation, the 1988 radiocarbon dating at Oxford, Arizona and ETH Zurich to AD 1260-1390 at 95% confidence, later statistical reanalyses and the explanation that critics' contamination and repair arguments are not accepted by most experts, the 1532 fire in which molten silver burned holes later patched by Poor Clare nuns, the move to Turin in 1578, the Church neither endorsing nor rejecting authenticity with John Paul II saying the Church has no competence on the question, the fire of 11 April 1997, and public displays including 2010, 2013 and 2015. It gives the Lirey and d'Arcis dates inconsistently (1353/1355, 1389/1390)
  • Wikipedia, 'Conservation-restoration of the Shroud of Turin' — the fire of 4 December 1532 and spring 1534 patching, the fire at Turin Cathedral on 11 April 1997, the glass case, Mario Trematore breaking it with a sledgehammer with another fireman helping, and the Shroud surviving unscathed
  • Aleteia, 'Fireman who saved the holy Shroud from the 1997 fire tells the story' (2022) — Trematore's account that firefighters smashed the case with sledgehammers on the night of April 11-12, 1997, and removed the casket as the dome was judged at risk of collapsing

Nearby on the Dark Atlas

  • The Duke Stabbed at Mass on St Stephen's Day

    On December 26, 1476, three Milanese courtiers killed Galeazzo Maria Sforza in the church of Santo Stefano. One was cut down on the spot. The other two were executed, and one went to it quoting Latin.

  • The Heretic Burned By The Reformers Who Fled Rome

    Calvin's Geneva burned a brilliant Spanish physician for his beliefs, then, centuries later, erected a monument of atonement.

  • The Empress Who Walked Away From Her Own Murder

    Stabbed through the heart by an assassin who wanted someone else, she got up, brushed herself off, and kept walking.

  • The Tragic Life Behind Frankenstein

    The real 1818 novel is nothing like the lumbering movie monster — and the woman who wrote it lived a life as tragic as her fiction.

All stories near Italy →

← Back to the archive